Muriel is collecting eggs inside the henhouse while Courage is nearby on the ground asleep. A masked woman arrives and proceeds to whack him with a washbasin. When Muriel comes out, she thinks that the woman is Courage's friend playing with him. She invites her over to the farmhouse to stay for a while. At the dinning room, the masked woman reveals her name to be Kitty. She explains to the Bagges about her best friend Bunny, who fell in love with a gangster named Mad Dog, and that "all dogs are evil." However, upon realizing Mad Dog’s true colors, Bunny tried to flee, but was eventually overpowered and restrained, and Mad Dog forced Kitty to stay away from them for good. With no where else to go, Kitty was forced to take shelter elsewhere.
After dinner, Kitty attacks Courage twice more, when he is alone in the living room watching television and later alone again in the bathroom plugging the toilet. Muriel makes a bed for the guest in the garret. At night, Courage spies on Kitty and sees how she plays with a toy mouse, which is a reminder of Bunny. Once Kitty takes off her mask, Courage shrieks and is convinced that the Mask is evil. He tells Muriel and Eustace, but they don't believe him. So, in an attempt to protect them both, Courage locks his owners and Kitty in their rooms, and steals the toy mouse, supposedly as evidence for the police.
Courage drives to the Diner and learns from Charlie the Mouse that Mad Dog has Bunny in his apartment. Meanwhile, Muriel, Eustace, and Kitty try to get out of their rooms. Kitty succeeds and goes to look for the stolen toy mouse, assuming that Courage stole it. Courage soon finds Bunny and saves her from Mad Dog, who gets involved in a high-speed chase. Mad Dog's car winds up driving on the railroad tracks and is eventually smashed by a powerful locomotive hauling an Amtrak passenger train, killing him.
As Courage and Bunny escape, they see Kitty on the train, who pulls Bunny up with her. As the train speeds off, the two happy friends thank Courage and admit that not all dogs are evil. In the morning, Courage returns home, and Muriel tells him that Eustace now uses the mask Kitty left behind in order to protect his face whenever he does dangerous work.
Muriel: "Ohhhh Eustace the kitty was right about you. You can't fix a thing!"
Eustace: "Oh yeah? You want some chocolate?"
Charlie: "He and his gang live down the road. You know where. After you get Bunny out of there tell her Charlie says 'Hey.'"
This is one the rare instances of an episode from the series that is considered controversial. The reason for this is due to the topic of lesbian relationships, which is negatively looked down upon by many religions, mainly Christianity.
- This is the first appearance of Kitty, Bunny, and Mad Dog.
- The second two-parter, after The Tower of Dr. Zalost.
- Although the train in this episode was powered by a steam locomotive, it has an air horn. Which is based on a NYC Defryuss Hudson. And the Diesel horn Sound effect is from Sound ideas
- Courage's paranoia gets the better of him in this episode. Kitty only hated him because he was a dog. She posed no threat to Muriel and Eustace at all.
- Whenever Courage thinks about Muriel and Eustace, only Eustace's lower body is shown. We see nothing above his waist. Also, during his final thought bubble, he only rescues Muriel from Kitty's mouth despite the fact that Eustace was devoured too.
- John R. Dilworth has stated in an interview that he "could not believe Cartoon Network allowed this episode to be aired" due to its strong themes of abuse, relationships, and domestic violence.
- This episode ranks among the deepest Courage episodes, with the above themes, as well as misogyny, misandry, domestic and genre violence and potentially homosexuality.
- It is possible that Bunny might be bisexual or at least Mad Dog thinks she is due to his jealousy for Kitty.
- Given the only other known cat that Courage knows is Katz, his fear of Kitty might be justified.
- The episode's title is a reference to the 1994 movie of the same name starring Jim Carrey.